The Sixth Sense – Kentucky Derby Rankings: 4/3/2010

4 04 2010

With only 4 Saturdays remaining before the 136th running of the Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs, it’s time to once again wade into the murky, otherworldly ether of the 3-year-old division of thoroughbred horse racing and attempt to find reason.  That task has become easier thanks to the HD broadcasts of the Wood Memorial and Santa Anita Derby on NBC last Saturday and the jaw dropping 109 Beyer earning performance of Eskendereya in the Wood.

The victory solidified the colt with the Egyptian name as the top contender and most likely favorite for the first Saturday in May.  That doesn’t mean it’s a slam dunk that Eskendereya will win the Derby. Remember, just last year we were in virtually the same position after I Want Revenge wowed us with an impressive Wood victory only to wind up being a late scratch on Derby morning. For now though, it’s clear that Eskendereya deserves to be considered the top of the class.

Of course, Eskendereya wasn’t the only show in town.  American Lion wired the field to win the Grade 3 Illinois Derby, and across the nation in California Sidney’s Candy turned in another brilliant front running performance that featured an odd, nearly catastrophic ride for the favored Lookin at Lucky.  Evidently Garrett Gomez went after Victor Espinoza (who was aboard longshot Who’s Up) after the race.

The victories by American Lion, Eskendereya, and Sidney’s Candy bring up another question for the 2010 Derby:  pace.  So far it looks like any number of contenders on the graded earnings list will be on-or-near the lead.  At some point that has to factor into the equation when ranking these horses.

That being said, I’m not sure if it’s going to matter, and there’s simply no way to ignore the dominating nature of Eskendereya’s performance.  Without hesitation, I move the colt above my beloved Odysseus in this, our sixth installment of the Derby rankings.

  • #1 Eskendereya

Monster performances in the G2 Fountain of Youth and G1 Wood Memorial establish the Todd Pletcher trained son of Giant’s Causeway as THE horse to beat in the Kentucky Derby.  Worthy favorite.  If there is a weakness, perhaps he will be more vulnerable with a hotly contested pace?

  • #2 Odysseus

I may be dropping him from my top spot, and a sub-par performance this weekend could leave him on the outside of the top 20 on the graded earnings list headed to the Kentucky Derby, but I’m loyal to my favorites – and there’s been something about this chestnut beauty that has stirred my emotions since I first spotted him after the allowance score at Tampa Bay Downs.  I’d prefer the Arkansas Derby be his final prep, but it looks like he could face Interactif and Aikenite in the Toyota Blue Grass instead.  God go with you wherever your travels may take you, big red horse!

  • #3 Lookin at Lucky

Like many, there was a moment in the Santa Anita Derby where I feared for the sport that one of our bigger 3-year-old “stars” was injured.  Thankfully, it appears that the son of Smart Strike came out of the race okay, although his jockey was a bit fired up.  Bob Baffert didn’t get the trip he wanted in the Santa Anita Derby, but the gutsy way  he fought back for 3rd after being nearly stopped on the track showed what this horse is all about.  He may be a bit crazy in the head, but he’s the kind of guy you’re always going to respect in a fight.

  • #4 Sidney’s Candy

It feels almost sacrilegious to rank a “speed horse” 4th on this list.  I’m sure there will be numerous folks pointing out the folly for having done so, without even reading what follows.  The fact of the matter is that I’m not putting this horse here because I believe he has the 4th best shot to win the Derby.  I’m putting him here because I think he has earned the right to be ranked among the top 4 horses prepping for the Derby.  It looks to me like the son of Candy Ride can answer the distance question, but the way the Derby is shaping up the pace scenario will likely be an altogether different story.

  • #5  Ice Box

Given the potential pace setup for the Kentucky Derby, it seems as though a Grade 1 winning closer belongs in the top 5, even if he was dusted by Eskendereya in the G2 Fountain of Youth in February.  He was “off slow” that day, and may be in better form now.  His running style, his experience against the likely favorite, his G1 prestige, and the likely pace outlook for Kentucky Derby 136 all suggest he belongs in the discussion.

  • #6 Mission Impazible

Rousing victory for the son of Unbridled’s Song in the Grade 2 Louisiana Derby gives Rajiv Maragh something to think about with respect to the Kentucky Derby and Odysseus.

  • #7 Endorsement

The more I see of this colt, the more I like him.  Won the Grade 3 Sunland Derby in record time of 1:48.46 over Conveyance and Tempted to Tapit.  The  son of Distorted Humor seems to be peaking at the right time and I love his fast improving form.  Some question whether he is headed for a bounce in the KY Derby, and have suggested he’s just an inflated G3 winner (like Odysseus), but my gut tells me this is a better race horse than many yet realize.

  • #8 Awesome Act

Had the second worst trip of the day last Saturday (with top honors going to Lookin at Lucky) after being under a stranglehold from jockey Julien Leparoux in the early goings of the G1 Wood Memorial.  My guess is they were trying to force him to relax some early on.  A gorgeous looking son of Awesome Again, on his best stuff I think he’s a much better horse than what we saw, despite the thrashing the entire field took.  Jackson Bend, Schoolyard Dreams, and Awesome Act were fighting it out for the minor awards, and sir Awesome was able to hang on for show.  Needs a better trip to be a player in the Derby.

  • #9 Noble’s Promise

Will likely continue to be the Rodney Dangerfield horse of this list that gets no respect from outsiders.  In fact, I think he and Jackson Bend are the most routinely disrespected horses  of the entire crop, which is a shame considering these two give it their all each time they touch the track.  Yes, smart guys, I know he’s a son of Cuvee, but evidently someone has forgotten to tell this horse he doesn’t belong.  Over $700k  in graded earnings and a shot in the G1 Arkansas Derby up next.

  • #10 Interactif

Stays on this list because we need another off-the-pace type and he probably has as good a shot as any to win the Blue Grass this weekend and further solidify his graded earnings qualifications. I toyed with adding Setsuko to the top 10, but it looks like that one is “on the bubble.”  This colt could make some noise on national television this weekend.

Honorable Mention:

  • Blind Luck – likely Oaks favorite would seem to make some sense if they gave her a shot – she could probably beat many of these colts.
  • Jackson Bend – colt just keeps on hitting exactas – despite all the haters.
  • Pleasant Prince – 2nd place finisher of the G1 Florida Derby
  • Super Saver – will look for an improved performance this weekend
  • Drosselmeyer – Had a nice effort in the G2 Louisiana Derby
  • Dean’s Kitten – Not sure he beat anyone in the Lane’s End, but that was a 9 furlong Grade 2 victory.
  • Dublin – reunites with jockey Terry Thompson for the Grade 1 Arkansas Derby on 4/10.
  • Conveyance - was no match in the stretch for Endorsement in the G3 Sunland Derby.
  • Setsuko – closed well in the Santa Anita Derby, but may miss the graded earnings cutoff.  Was on our initial top list of the year.
  • Devil May Care – Todd Pletcher says the Bonnie Miss winner deserves to be in the discussion.

Up next up are the Grade 1 Toyota Blue Grass at Keeneland and the Grade 1 Arkansas Derby at Oaklawn Park.  We’ll have selections for each race available by Friday evening.  Last weekend 8 out of the 9 horses we gave out in our Derby Fever selections wound up hitting the board, with two top choice winners (Eskendereya and American Lion) along with a 2nd choice winner in Sidney’s Candy.


Comments : 16 Comments »
Tags: , , , , ,
Categories : Awesome Act, Endorsement, Eskendereya, horse racing, Horse Racing News, Ice Box, Interactif, Kentucky Derby Trail, Lookin at Lucky, Mission Impazible, Noble's Promise, Odysseus, Sidney's Candy

Toyota Blue Grass a solid betting race

10 04 2009

Saturday’s 85th running of the Grade 1 Toyota Blue Grass at Keeneland may not have the star appeal of the other Grade 1 preps along the Derby trail, but it might be one of the more appealing betting races of the season.   Value, particularly underneath in the exotics, will likely abound as the race has drawn 10 relatively evenely matched competitors. 

  1. Patena (R. Albarado Jr./ R. Dutrow Jr.) 10/1
  2. Join in the Dance (J. Velazquez / T. Pletcher) 10/1
  3. Theregoesjojo (C. Borel/ K. McPeek) 7/2
  4. Cliffy’s Future (J. L. Castanon/ D. Miller) 20/1
  5. Mafaaz (R. Hills/ J. Gosden) 12/1
  6. Terrain (J. Leparoux/ A. Stall Jr.) 6/1
  7. Loch Dubh (H. J. Thierot II/ J. Talley) 50/1
  8. General Quarters (E. Coa/ T. McCarthy) 15/1
  9. Charitable Man (A. Garcia/ K. McLaughlin) 4/1
  10.  Hold Me Back (K. Desormeaux/ W. Mott) 3/1*
  11.  Massone (G. Gomez/ R. McAnally) 12/1

Morning line favoritism has been awarded to Hold Me Back, largely based on his most recent victory in the Grade 2 Lane’s End on March 21 at Turfway Park.   The son of Giant’s Causeway perked up that day and displayed an apparent affinity for a synthetic surface.  Importantly, he also has shown he can win here at Keeneland, having done so against conditional allowance runners last October (including today’s rival Cliffy’s Future).   He also prevailed in a move I seldom play;  dirt to synthetic.  If you toss his 5th place finish on the dirt against Old Fashioned in the Remsen, he’s 3 for his remaining 3.   It’s interesting to note in his workout lines that he gest credit for a bullet over the dirt at Payson Park going 5 furlongs in 1:02.2, yet only ranks 15th out of 35 for his workout going the same two full seconds faster at Keeneland on Sunday.  He’s got the looks of a worthy favorite, but he doesn’t tower over the field.

Theregoesjojo is the second choice on the morning line at 7/2.  This guy looks like one of the best horses in this race, but once again I’m hesitant to support a dirt runner trying the artificial footing for the first time.    To his credit, he has defeated Quality Road, and ran respectably against both he and Dunkirk in the Florida Derby.  HIs trainer, Ken McPeek, is hitting at an even 20% clip over synthetic surfaces.  I’ve got mixed feelings about this guy in this spot.  I suspect he’ll run a good race, but I don’t think I can support him for the win.

Charitable Man is the horse that offers the most intrigue.  For starters, he’s a Lemon Drop, which I always enjoy playing.   You know he’ll be able to handle the distance, and trainer Kiaran McLaughlin has been giving this guy some solid works in preparation for his 2009 debut.   While he is going from dirt to synthetics like Theregoesjojo, I like his turf pedigree a bit more and would expect him to handle the surfact switch more confidently.  While he has yet to race this year, somebody in his camp has decided this colt hast the goods for the Kentucky Derby, as he’s among those who paid the early nomination fee for the first Saturday in May.   It’s worth noting that he beat two talented horses in the Futurity last year, both Friesan Fire and Flying Pegasus.  As Handride pointed out to me on Facebook earlier today, he evidently has his own blog.  You get the feeling this is the class of the field right here, and if he’s cranked up and ready to go – watch out!

European invader Mafaaz has already earned a birth in the Kentucky Derby.   In that way, much like Street Sense in 2007, he’s really here as a final tune up while his connections make the final determination about their chances  next month.  He looks to be in great form, and the only loss of his career was to Donativum, who went on to win the Breeders’ Cup Juvenile Turf last fall at Santa Anita.   He’s accomplished on both turf and synthetics, and will likely offer solid value on the board since many players will shy away from him due to unfamiliarity.   My advice?  Don’t ignore this guy.  I don’t think they would have shipped here if they didn’t truly believe they might have something.   Of course, as with most of the horses here, you really need to get a look at them in the post parade before you can make a final assessment.   That goes doubly true for Mafaaz since he doesn’t have a posted workout over the local service to give us any other indication on how he’s shipped. 

Terrain is a runner who looks capable of moving forward by virtue of essentially dropping in class.   He ran into Friesan Fire and Papa Clem in the Louisiana Derby, and prior to that was favored against Big Drama and West Side Bernie in the Delta Jackpot.  That was really his worst effort after rather uncharectersitically flashing early speed.   He’s actually finished ahead of Pioneer of the Nile, who is currently 4th in the public voting on our Kentucky Derby poll, in both the Breeder’s Futurity and the Breeder’s Cup Juvenile.  That’s really one of the most powerful angles you can find from a handicapping perspective in this entire race. 

I’m going to play the Lemon Drop like I usually do and go with Charitable Man for the win.   I’ll use Mafaaz, Terrain, and Hold Me Back underneath in place.  Add in General Quarters  and Theregoesjojo for show,  with Patena and Join in the Dance on the bottom of the Superfecta.  

Selections:

  • $20 Win #9 Charitable Man
  • $.10 Superfecta:  9/5,6,10/ 3,5,6,8,10/ 1,2,3,5,6,8,10 ($6.00)

The Toyota Blue Grass will be featured on TVG and again on tape delay on ESPN2 on Saturday.


Comments : 5 Comments »
Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,
Categories : Handicapping Selections, horse racing, Keeneland, Kentucky Derby Trail

The Pamplemousse and Quality Road get the job done.

1 03 2009

Track announcer Trevor Denman’s call was spot on as The Pamplemousse prepared to cross the finish line in Saturday’s running of the Grade 3 Sham at Santa Anita Park;

“…they would need to sprout wings to catch him…”

 

Indeed. The impressive son of Kafwain with the funny name (pronounced “pample-moose” in case, like me, your first inclination was to make it more of a “pimple mouse” enunciation) has now pulled off 3 straight victories in a row, with each one being an improvement on the last.   Julio Canani’s grapefruit has only one test left to pass out west on the road to the Kentucky Derby when he faces off against Pioneer of the Nile and (perhaps) Stardom Bound in the Santa Anita Derby in April. 

The Pamplemousse is a horse that has become quite popular with fans following the action out in California.  Visually, he’s an impressive colt that looks big and well put together to me.  If you haven’t had a chance to get up close and personal with him, you’re in luck; Mary Forney has been documenting him in the morning workouts and getting some always entertaining Julio Canani camera time and it’s all available on youtube.

 

Take the Points proved something to me by running fairly well for 2nd in the Sham.  Prior to the race I had mentioned that I’m not fond of horses shipping from east to west (especially not on such short notice), but he showed up and ran extremely well.  This might be a horse to keep an eye on as well.  Not many have the versatility to run big on both dirt and synthetics. I think this guy has a future in front of him.  Colonel John’s full brother Mr. Hot Stuff got up for third.

The challenge The Pamplemousse will likely have to overcome one of these days is to his front running, gate to wire style.  The only thing we need to see from this colt is that he can relax.  However, isn’t it somewhat more impressive that he’s doing this over the Santa Anita Pro Ride?  It’s not the most speed favoring track in recent memory and tends to play more like a turf course.   Plus, all he does is run the competition out of their shoes.  You’ve got to love that, but I’m still a bit cautious about his chances come the First Saturday in May. 

 

 

In the other major action of the day, Quality Road turned in a bit of a shocker in the Fountain of Youth.  Several of you had mentioned this horse as a runner you expected big things from, so I’m hoping there were a few cashed tickets out there amongst the faithful.  Me, I got burned by him as I expected him to be part of a hot pace.  That didn’t really develop right away, and by the time it did Quality Road was actually in good position to benefit from it stalking just behind This One’s for Phil.

My choice, Beethoven, ran on for third, but never really threatened.  Quality Road won in impressive fashion, absolutely blowing away This One’s for Phil in the stretch.  The win is the third quality performance that the aptly named Quality Road has turned out thus far in his career, and it looks like the son of Elusive Quality should be able to get some extra distance if trainer James Jerkens decides to point him towards either the Florida Derby or the Wood Memorial in early April.

I also thought Theregoesjojo was running very well late and it will be interesting to see where trainer Ken McPeek points this guy next.   For now though, Quality Road definitely looks like a colt to keep an eye on in the coming months.  Obviously the Pamplemousse was already on most everyone’s radar, but it’s always nice to welcome a relatively new colt to the discussion, so come on down Quality Road and pull up a chair. 

Next weekend should bring even more intrigue as we get to see Haynesfield, Imperial Council, Mr. Fantasy, and others in the Grade 3 Gotham at Aqueduct.  Things are starting to get interesting, that’s for sure.  If you’re curious about my top 10 Derby contenders at the moment, I’d rank ‘em like this:

  1. Old Fashioned
  2. Dunkirk
  3. Pioneer of the Nile
  4. Friesan Fire
  5. The Pamplemousse
  6. Patena (must live up to the hype to prove this position though)
  7. Quality Road (rocketing up my list)
  8. Haynesfield (will get toughest test yet in the Gotham, but has earned this ranking thus far)
  9. Imperial Council (is he the real deal?)
  10. Stardom Bound (get the feeling she’ll head to the Oaks instead of the Derby)

Comments : 23 Comments »
Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,
Categories : Gulfstream Park, Handicapping Selections, Horse Racing News, Kentucky Derby Trail, Quality Road, Santa Anita, The Pamplemousse


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.